Rose Curves: Why Four Makes Eight Petals
One short rule draws a whole garden: r = cos(kθ). k = 3 gives three petals, so you'd expect four to give four. It gives eight. We build the rose from polar coordinates (which way to face, how far to walk), wrap a cosine wave around the centre so each hump becomes a petal, and see what a negative distance means: walk backwards. That's why odd k redraws its own petals and even k fills the gaps. Then fractions (petals that overlap and take longer to close), the square root of two (a flower that never closes), the two spinning circles hiding inside every rose, the toy wheel that draws one, and a surprise: every petal fills exactly half its slice of the circle. Plus Guido Grandi's "geometric flowers", Maurer roses, and where roses turn up in chemistry, microphones and watch dials.
Chapters
- 0:00 Intro
- 0:49 Which way, how far
- 1:19 A breathing radius
- 1:53 Walking backwards
- 2:29 Odd and even
- 3:08 Fractions
- 3:49 Never closing
- 4:27 Two circles
- 5:09 A wheel in a ring
- 5:51 Half the slice
- 6:25 Who named them
- 7:02 Where you'll meet them
- 7:40 Draw it yourself
- 8:13 Recap and next
Cheat sheet
- Rose curve: r = cos(kθ), a distance that rises and falls as the angle θ turns; a negative r means walk backwards (the opposite side)
- Whole k: odd k → k petals (closes after half a turn); even k → 2k petals (a full turn). k = 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 → 1, 4, 3, 8, 5, 12
- Why: walking backwards = jumping half a turn; for odd k that lands on a forward petal, for even k in a gap
- Each petal is 180°/k wide
- Fractions k = p/q (lowest terms): both odd → p petals, closes after q half turns; otherwise 2p petals after q full turns (3/2 → 6, 5/3 → 5, 7/4 → 14)
- Irrational k (like √2): never closes; its line comes as close as you like to every point of the disk
- Two circles: cos(kθ)·e^(iθ) = ½e^(i(k+1)θ) + ½e^(−i(k−1)θ)
- Area: every petal fills exactly half its slice of the circle; even roses cover half the circle, odd roses a quarter
- Maurer rose: points on r = sin(nθ) at 0°, d°, 2d°, … joined by straight lines (n = 6, d = 71)
Sources
- Rose (mathematics)
- MacTutor, Guido Grandi
- MacTutor, Rhodonea curves
- Grandi, Florum geometricorum manipulus (Phil. Trans., 1723)
- Maurer, A Rose is a Rose... (The American Mathematical Monthly, 1987)
- Maurer rose
- Hypotrochoid (the wheel in a ring)
- Real spherical harmonics (d orbitals)
- Rose engine lathe
Transcript
This flower is drawn by one short rule: r equals the cosine of k theta. Change the number k, and you get a different flower. k equals three gives three petals. So you'd expect four to give four. It gives eight.
Five gives five again, and six gives twelve. Fractions make petals that overlap, and some numbers make a flower that never closes at all. By the end of this video, you'll see why even numbers double the petals, what fractions do, why every petal fills exactly half its slice of the circle, and the two spinning circles hiding inside every rose.
This is Just Known. From unknown, to known. Beauty of Math, episode ten: rose curves, and why four makes eight petals. Usually, we place points by going across and up. There's another way, the one our sunflower seeds used: say which way to face, and how far to walk.
That's polar coordinates: an angle, theta, and a distance, r. Hold the distance at one while the angle turns all the way round, and you draw a circle. Let the distance grow as you turn, and you get a spiral. A polar graph is just a rule: for each direction, how far to go. Now let the distance rise and fall as you turn.
Take the wave cosine of three theta. On an ordinary graph, it rises and falls three times for every full turn of the angle. Now wrap it around. As the ray sweeps round, the point's distance from the centre follows the wave. At theta equals zero, the wave is at its top, so the point is a full step out.
As the wave falls to zero, the point slides back to the centre. That hump of the wave becomes one petal. Each petal is a hundred and eighty over k degrees wide: here, sixty degrees. Then the wave dips below zero. What's a negative distance?
Face the way the ray points, and walk backwards. So while the ray sweeps through the next sixty degrees, the point draws a petal on the opposite side of the centre. Then the wave comes back up, and the point walks forwards again. After half a turn, you have three petals: two drawn forwards, and one drawn backwards. Now keep sweeping.
The second half turn draws the same three petals again, exactly on top of the first ones, with forwards and backwards swapped. That's why three gives three. Now try four. The petals are forty-five degrees wide, and this time the backward petals land in the gaps between the forward ones, instead of on top of them. Nothing is drawn twice, so it takes a full turn, and you get four forward petals and four backward ones: eight.
Here's the rule. Walking backwards is the same as jumping half a turn. With an odd k, half a turn takes you from a dip in the wave to a peak, so the backward petals cover the forward ones. With an even k, it takes you from a dip to another dip, so the backward petals fill the gaps. Odd k gives k petals.
Even k gives two k. k doesn't have to be a whole number. Try three halves. Now one turn isn't enough: the wave and the turning ray fall out of step, and the curve keeps going, laying new petals over the old ones. It closes after two full turns, with six petals.
Five thirds closes after one and a half turns, with five. Write k as a fraction in lowest terms, p over q. When p and q are both odd, you get p petals, and the curve closes after q half turns. Otherwise, you get two p petals, after q full turns. Lay them out in a grid, and you have a whole gallery of flowers.
So what if k isn't a fraction at all? Take the square root of two. It's close to seven fifths, so after two and a half turns, the curve looks like the seven-petal rose, and it nearly closes, missing its starting point by about a fortieth of a petal. But only nearly. The square root of two is even closer to forty-one over twenty-nine, and after fourteen and a half turns, it misses by less than a thousandth.
It never closes. It keeps laying down new petals, each pass a little turned from the last, and given enough turns, its line passes as close as you like to every point of the disk. Here's what's really going on. Remember Euler's formula from the last episode: e to the i theta is a point turning round a circle. And the cosine is two of those circles, spinning opposite ways, averaged.
Multiply it by the ray's direction, e to the i theta, and every rose is the sum of two arrows, each half a step long. One spins forwards, k plus one times as fast as the ray. The other spins backwards, k minus one times as fast. When the two arrows line up, you're a full step out, at the tip of a petal. When they point opposite ways, they cancel, and you're back at the centre.
It's the circles from our Fourier episode, with just two circles. The same two circles hide in a toy you may have played with: a toothed wheel rolling inside a ring, with a pen through a hole in the wheel. The wheel's centre goes round one way, while the wheel itself spins the other way. Usually that draws loops that miss the middle. But choose a wheel two thirds the size of the ring, put the pen halfway out from its centre, and it draws the three-petal rose.
The trick is that the pen sits exactly as far from the wheel's centre as the wheel's centre is from the middle of the ring. So every time those two point opposite ways, the pen passes straight through the middle. A different wheel and pen give the eight-petal rose for k equals four. Here's a surprise. Every petal fills exactly half of its slice of the circle.
The area of a polar shape adds up one half r squared as the angle sweeps, and cos squared averages exactly one half over every wave, whatever k is. So each petal gets half of its slice. An even rose's slices cover the whole circle, so every even rose, four petals or forty, covers exactly half the circle. An odd rose's petals only point in half the directions, with gaps as wide as the petals, so every odd rose covers exactly a quarter of the circle. Rose curves were studied by Guido Grandi, a monk and mathematician in Pisa, in the early seventeen hundreds.
He named them rhodonea, from the Greek word for rose, and in 1728 he published a book about them, called Flores geometrici: geometric flowers. Two and a half centuries later, in 1987, Peter Maurer found a new way to draw them. Take the twelve-petal rose, step around it in jumps of a fixed angle, say seventy-one degrees, and join the points with straight lines. After three hundred and sixty jumps, you get patterns like these, now called Maurer roses. You'll meet roses in chemistry.
Slice through one of the d orbitals of an atom, and its wave, going round that plane, follows cos two theta: four lobes, with a plus sign along one axis and a minus sign along the other, just like our forward and backward petals. In sound, a figure-eight microphone picks up sound in proportion to cos theta: fully from the front, nothing from the side, and fully again from behind, but with its sign flipped. And a rose engine, a lathe that rocks the work back and forth as it turns, has cut flower-like patterns into watch faces and decorative metalwork for centuries. You can draw any rose in a few lines of code. Pick k.
Sweep the angle t once around, in small steps. At each step, the distance r is the cosine of k t. Turn the distance and the angle into a point: across is r cos t, and up is r sin t, measured from the middle of the canvas. Join the points with a line. With k equals four, you get the eight petals.
Set k to five thirds and turns to one and a half, and watch the petals overlap. The code is in the description. Let's recap. A rose is a distance that rises and falls as you turn: r equals cos k theta. Each hump of the wave draws a petal, and a negative distance draws one backwards.
Odd k draws its petals twice, so it has k of them. Even k fills the gaps, so it has two k. Fractions overlap and take longer to close, and some numbers never close at all. And every petal fills exactly half its slice. Next time: Bézier curves, the smooth curves behind almost every letter on your screen.
This is Just Known. From unknown, to known.
Note: every curve, point and number on screen is computed; pictures marked "illustration" are schematic.
Narration voice generated with Google Gemini text-to-speech.
